Put the claim on the canvas. Then test it.
A repeatable path from what the team believes to what the evidence can support.

Step one

Ask the question
Start a loop with the question you keep arguing about. Prima drafts the hypothesis. Edit it until it says what the team actually believes.
Step two

Attach the evidence
Add interview notes, funnel numbers, support tickets, links, and files. Put each one in the section that tests the hypothesis. Ask Prima to mark whether it supports or contradicts the claim.
Step three

Close the question. Keep the case.
Record the verdict with the evidence still attached. When the question comes back, reopen the loop instead of rebuilding the reasoning from memory.
Close the question. Keep the case.
The claim is visible. The evidence is attached. The verdict has somewhere to live.